an you talk, Ros?" Lindsay asked cautiously when she was finally put through to Rosalind's office extension.

"Yes, I'm alone. Have you got any news?" she inquired eagerly.

"Progress at last. I think I know who our burglar is."

"That's terrific news! How on earth did you find out?" Rosalind asked, her voice full of admiration.

"Trade secret," Lindsay replied modestly. "But I can tell you that the burglary appears to have been carried out by a rent boy called Alex McNaught. Does the name mean anything to you?"

"Can't say it does. But if he's one of Harry's little friends, there's no reason why it should. I never meet them. But if he knew his way around the building... Does this tie in with Alison's murder, like you thought it might?"

"I can't quite see how. Why do you ask?" Lindsay asked.

"It's just that... It might be nothing, but she did a five-part series on AIDS for the Clarion last year. About how it's spreading into the heterosexual community. Maybe she ran into him then?"

Lindsay's thoughts were racing. Rosalind's words seemed to confirm her hunch about a connection. Casting Harry as the "political hot potato" suddenly seemed far more credible. On impulse, she stalled Rosalind with, "Possibly. It'll have to be checked out, though."

"I agree. Do you know where to find this McNaught?" Rosalind demanded.

"I think so. But before I go any further, I think I'd better speak to Harry. When is he coming up?" Lindsay asked.

"He'll be here late tonight. He was supposed to be spending the weekend in Kinradie, but after this business, he cancelled his Saturday morning surgery, and he's not going up till Sunday. Do you want to come round later on?"

Lindsay thought rapidly. With Ruth and Antonis coming for dinner, she really didn't want to commit herself to anything more that evening. "Not tonight, Ros," she said. "Sophie and I have got dinner guests. Business rather than pleasure, if you catch my drift."

"No problem. Why don't you come round for breakfast in the morning and take it from there?"

"That would be perfect. What time?"

"Nine okay? Harry should have surfaced by then. He'll be your friend for life after this, Lindsay. And so will I, come to that."

"Don't fall at my feet with gratitude till I've actually got Harry's papers back," Lindsay warned. "It might not be entirely straightforward, I shouldn't have to tell you that. Tell Harry it might cost him to get his stuff back."

"He won't quibble, don't worry about that. He'll think it's cheap at the price to preserve his respectability," Rosalind said bitterly. "See you tomorrow morning."

Lindsay put down the phone and started preparing for the evening's dinner party. Plenty of good food and good wine to relax them and put them at their ease, she had decided. She'd worked the menu out and stopped to do the shopping on the way back from her sticky encounter with Claire, and she surveyed her purchases with satisfaction. She wondered if she could claim her outlay back from Claire as a legitimate business expense. Maybe she should have broached the subject before she accused Claire of murder, Lindsay thought ironically.

First, she put some water on to boil, then quartered the two pheasants she had bought from the game butcher. There was a glut of pheasants this year, they'd never be cheaper, he had informed her as he'd talked her into buying the brace. She tipped the pheasants into the boiling water, then added carrots, onions, and spices. She left it to simmer while she chopped vegetables ready for the soup she was planning as a starter.

Once the pheasant was cooked, Lindsay stripped the flesh from the bones and set about assembling the complicated dish of bastilla: layers of filo pastry, pheasant, flaked almonds, and egg custard. After half an hour's work, she looked with satisfaction at the finished pastry parcel, all ready to be popped in the oven to cook. The soup was also bubbling merrily. For dessert, she'd bought some Italian ice cream which she planned to serve with a sauce of pureed fruit from the rumtopf Sophie prepared every year with 160 proof Austrian rum. If they hadn't drunk enough wine to loosen their tongues, she'd get them pissed on the pudding.

By six, everything was ready, and Lindsay poured herself a glass of wine on her way to the bath. Sophie arrived from work just as Lindsay was towelling herself dry. She looked stunning in a scarlet and cream leisure suit. "Doctors never looked like this when I was young," Lindsay commented as Sophie pulled her into her arms and kissed her heartily.

"Probably just as well! How's my favourite detective today? Did Barry Ostler eat you alive?" she asked.

"He was just like the Red Queen," Lindsay replied. "Wanted me to believe six impossible things before breakfast."

"But did you get Harry's papers back?"

"Not as such," Lindsay admitted. "But I've got a pretty shrewd idea where they are. I'm meeting Harry for breakfast tomorrow, and then we'll go and see if we can get them."

"There's a treat for you," Sophie teased. "A breakfast meeting with one of our leading politicians. Rather you than me."

"What's he like?" Lindsay asked, following her through to the bathroom where Sophie quickly stripped off and dived into the shower.

"He's a pain," Sophie shouted. "The sort who makes you feel distinctly iffy about gay solidarity. He's basically a chancer. He tells people what he thinks they want to hear."

"Sounds like the perfect recipe for a politician," Lindsay called back.

"Harry's problem is that Ros got all the brains in that family. Harry's not half as bright as he'd like people to think he is, which is why he's only ever going to be a back bencher. Speaking of recipes, what time are our guests due?"

Lindsay checked her watch. "In an hour."

"Oh good," said Sophie, emerging dripping from the shower. "Time for some fun, then."

Antonis wiped his mouth delicately on his napkin and favoured Lindsay with his most ingratiating smile. Looking at him, she could see exactly why Ruth had fallen for him. He had pale olive skin that hadn't gone sallow even in the depths of the Scottish winter. Lindsay suspected him of patronising the sunbeds at the Western Baths. His deep-set brown eyes oozed a sincerity she found spurious. A full moustache drew attention away from his aquiline nose and failed to cover a cruel twist to his full mouth. "May I compliment you on the exquisite dish, Lindsay? I have not tasted such fine pastry since I left Greece," he said in his precise English with its faint trace of an accent.

"If I was you, Lindsay, I'd take that as a bit of a backhanded compliment. In my book, the Greeks don't go down among the great pastry cooks of the world," Ruth said with a giggle in her voice that Lindsay suspected had a lot to do with the amount of Chardonnay she'd drunk. Her own muddy complexion was flushed and her eyes were glazed over.

Antonis frowned slightly. "Do not mock at me, Ruthie," he said softly but with a hint of menace.

Ruth flushed, but before anyone could say more, Lindsay stepped into the breach. "I'm glad you enjoyed it. I must say I had a lot of fun cooking it. I missed cooking anything more elaborate than pasta when I was in Italy. There's a limit to what you can do with a couple of gas rings and a grill."

"Are you now back for good?" Antonis asked politely.

"I don't really know," Lindsay replied. "I'm not flavour of the month as far as journalism is concerned, and I don't really know what else I'm capable of doing to earn a living." She took a deep breath. The conversation so far had been superficial to the point of boredom. It was time she got to work. "And the changes there have been while I was away certainly haven't been for the better. Imagine how I felt, coming home to find one of my mates behind bars for murdering one of my ex-lovers!"

"Did you really not know anything about... about Alison till you got back?" Ruth asked, pushing back the mousey wisps of hair that had escaped from her inefficiently constructed French pleat.

Lindsay shook her head. "Not a thing. It completely shattered me when I found out what had happened."

"It was a devastating experience for all of us," Antonis said gravely, playing with the stem of his wine glass. Lindsay noticed with a shiver of distaste that even his fingers were covered with fine black hairs.

"Jackie especially, considering she didn't do it," Sophie said drily, getting up to fetch another bottle of wine.

Ruth nodded vigorously. "I've never been able to believe she was guilty," she said sagely.

"Why's that, Ruth?" Lindsay asked. "After all, it was partly your evidence that convicted her."

Ruth looked as if she might burst into tears. "I know. I... I could hardly sleep for days afterwards. But I couldn't lie, could I? Not about what I heard. But it seemed so... so coldblooded. To make love to her, then to do that."

Antonis ran a hand through his luxuriant dark hair and said in the exaggeratedly polite tone of voice one uses to a small child who is letting the side down in public, "But I have told you before, Ruthie, we do not know what took place between them. Alison could be very provoking. I have watched her deliberately goad people to anger."

"I know, darling. But Jackie? I mean, we knew her. She was always so..." Ruth tailed off under his gaze.

"Alison must have said something to provoke her to fury," Antonis stated with an air of finality. He drained his glass and refilled it from the fresh bottle.

"It must be a terrible memory for you to live with, Ruth," Sophie said. "To think that if you'd only done something when you heard them quarrelling, Alison might still be alive."

Ruth's bottom lip trembled, but before she could speak, Antonis butted in authoritatively. "Ruth has tortured herself enough with that thought. I have told her, there was nothing she could have done. Even if she had diverted Jackie that day, there would have been another time."

"Que sera, sera, eh?" Lindsay said. Antonis' attempts to cut short any discussion of Alison's murder had made her even more determined to pursue it. "But you'd already left by the time of the actual murder, hadn't you, Ruth?"

Ruth seized Lindsay's comment like a drowning woman a raft. "That's right," she replied. "I had gone back to the gallery. I had some clients to phone, and the girl who runs the gallery for me had gone off early to the dentist. But it never occurred to me that it was anything other than a tiff. Then when I got back about seven, the whole block was in an uproar. There were policemen everywhere. I nearly collapsed when I heard the news."

"Luckily, I came home soon after Ruth," Antonis said. "She was in a state of complete terror."

Lindsay cleared the dishes and brought the ice cream to the table. "That's funny," she said. "I thought someone had told me you were there too all afternoon."

"You must have misunderstood," he said, fixing her with a suspicious look. "I was out all day. I went through to Edinburgh to have lunch with my literary agent, then I visited some friends at the university."

"It must have been a terrible blow to you both," Lindsay continued relentlessly. "She was very close to the two of you."

"I'm surprised you let Antonis near Alison, Ruth," Sophie said lightly. "After all, she had a nasty habit of poaching other people's property."

Antonis smiled politely, revealing slightly crooked but brilliant teeth. "Ah, but Ruth knows I am devoted to her only." He was fiddling with his wine glass again, throwing quizzical glances at Lindsay and Sophie as he listened to his wife.

"I think a lot of that has been exaggerated," Ruth said primly. "A lot of rumour and gossip. If half of it were true, well, there would have been a lot of people rejoicing at her death, wouldn't there? But everyone was really upset."

"They'd be bloody silly if they did dance on her grave with a police investigation in full swing," Sophie muttered.

"I think Ruth has a point," Lindsay said, pouring oil on the deliberately troubled waters. Sophie was playing her prearranged part of grit in the oyster almost too well. "But on the other hand, if Jackie hadn't been arrested, I think she and Claire would have been keeping very quiet about her connection with Alison."

"But didn't people know about it already?" Ruth asked.

"If you hadn't lived in the same block as Alison, would you have known?" Ruth shook her head at Lindsay's question. "And you were her closest friend. So it's fair to assume there must be other people out there with sufficient motives that no one knows about. Ice cream and fruit sauce, anyone?"

Lindsay dished up the dessert as the conversation continued. Antonis leaned back in his chair and said, "Motives are all very well. But no one is interested in motives now. There is someone paying the price for the crime. That keeps the police happy."

"But she's innocent!" Lindsay protested.

Antonis shrugged expressively. "Excuse me, I do not mean to be rude. I know she is a friend of yours. But I did not know the lady in question very well. You say she is innocent. But a court has said otherwise."

"And that's the end of the matter?" Sophie enquired casually, spooning the rich fruit sauce over her ice cream.

Again, he shrugged. "It should be. You Scots are so proud of your judicial process."

"So we just forget about it? Even if a mistake has been made? Even if the murderer is free now? Relaxing after a good dinner like us?" Lindsay asked, deliberately not looking at anyone.

Antonis' dark eyes narrowed. "There is still the small matter of proof."

"I think what Lindsay's getting at is that by examining the motives of other people it might be possible to come up with enough reasonable doubt to get Jackie out of prison," Sophie said.

"There must be some clue somewhere as to who her other lovers were," Lindsay said. "Didn't she keep a diary or anything? Ruth, you were her best friend. You must have some ideas."

Antonis froze with a spoonful of fruit halfway to his mouth, and cast a startled look at his wife. But Ruth only shook her head. "You know how secretive she could be. And there wasn't any sign of a diary or anything among her papers."

"Did you have to go through them, then?" Lindsay probed.

Ruth played nervously with her fork and spoon. "No. But I helped her mother pack everything up after the police had finished with the flat. We didn't really look at anything... we just packed all her letters and cuttings and computer discs into boxes. Neither of us could bear to read anything that would remind us of her. We were still in shock, you see. Her mother took it all home to Dundee with her. I suppose one day she'll be able to bring herself to..." Ruth tailed off, looking as if she was about to burst into tears.

"So no one actually looked through it? Not even the police?" Lindsay asked.

"I don't know. I don't think so. It didn't look as if it had been disturbed," Ruth said.

Antonis leaned forward and put his strong, hairy forearms on the table. "Why should they have studied her documents?" he asked intensely. "They already had their hands on Alison's killer."

"True," Lindsay sighed, pushing away her empty plate and lighting up a cigarette.

"Must we carry on talking about this?" Ruth suddenly said. "I'm sorry but I just find it so..."

"It is distressing," Antonis agreed with a heavy finality in his voice that even Lindsay couldn't argue with. "And it is in the past now. I think we should leave the dead in peace. Tell me, Sophie, what progress are you making in the care of your AIDS patients?"

Sophie closed the door behind Ruth and Antonis with a huge sigh of relief. "That," she complained as she returned to the living room, "was above and beyond the call of duty." She collapsed on the sofa with a groan. "They are dire!"

"I know," Lindsay commiserated. "I'm sorry. Let me get you another brandy."

"Please," Sophie begged. "Promise me we don't have to have them round for dinner ever again."

"I promise. I'll tell you something, though. That Antonis is a very cool customer. If I hadn't known he was one of Alison's lovers, I'd never have guessed from that performance," Lindsay announced as she poured Sophie's drink.

"And he trotted out his alibi as if he'd been waiting for months to get the chance to parade it before someone. Makes you wonder, doesn't it?"

"It sure does. Maybe I should take a little look at Antonis' movements. Though I don't quite know how I'm going to manage it. You performed beautifully, by the way," Lindsay congratulated her as she handed her a glass of brandy.

"Perhaps I've finally found my natural role in life. Ms. Nasty to your Ms. Nice. So, what do you think? Any closer to an answer?"

Lindsay shrugged. "What is it the song says? 'There are more questions than answers, And the more I find out, the less I know!' " She paced the floor as she worked through the facts she had gathered. Past experience had taught her that the best way to order her thoughts was to bounce them off someone. And when it came to providing her with stimulating responses, Sophie had already proved herself that evening.

"Claire has no alibi, and she has motive," Lindsay began, ticking people off on her fingers as she paced. She worked her way through Claire, Jimmy Mills, Ian Mclntosh, Ruth and Antonis, and concluded, "What we are distinctly lacking is any proof."

"What about the thumbprint that you told me about? Couldn't we get prints from all those suspects and see if any of them match?" Sophie suggested.

Lindsay sighed. "I guess it might have to come to that. But I can't see the police being very cooperative. And I really haven't the faintest idea if you can get freelance fingerprint experts to check out any prints we might obtain by subterfuge. I don't know, Sophie. I'm completely confused." She threw herself down on the sofa beside Sophie.

Sophie tickled the back of her neck, sending shivers of pleasure down Lindsay's spine. "The darkest hour is just before the dawn," she consoled. "Come on, let's go to bed. Maybe sleeping on it will help to clarify your thoughts."

Lindsay grinned. "Personally, I've always found that vigorous physical activity is a great mental catalyst."

"So go out for a jog!"